Surveillance Footage Leads to a Charge of Insurance Fraud

A 63-year-old truck driver filed a workers’ compensation claim alleging hip and wrist injuries after he fell into a pothole while trying to open a gate on his employer’s property. The incident occurred on a rainy morning and was caught on the employer’s surveillance camera.

Thanks to the collaborative and proactive efforts of the ICW Group Claims Examiner and Special Investigations Unit (SIU), statements were taken from the employer, who also provided the video footage. The video observed the man exit his truck and attempt to open the gate. At no time, however, was he seen falling, slipping, or appearing to injure himself. 

Additionally, in statements to doctors, he denied any prior injuries to the claimed body parts. Contrary to what he said, medical records and new imaging revealed a history of issues in these areas, which he later admitted. Although doctors did not conclude if his alleged injuries were new or aggravated, it furthered the suspicion of his motive to make a false claim.

Following the investigation, ICW Group’s SIU presented the case to the District Attorney, who charged the man with four counts of insurance fraud, including the filing of a false claim and making false statements. He remains innocent until proven guilty.

Caught on Tape

Surveillance cameras in or around a business not only serve as a deterrent for crime but can be helpful to a workers’ compensation claim investigation. Video surveillance can help validate a legitimate injury or refute a false injury claim. Employees who know that their actions might be caught on film may be less likely to stage an accident. 

This and other tips to prevent fraudulent claims in the workplace can be found on the ICW Group policyholder website. There you have access to informative webinars and various fraud materials that can aid in detecting and mitigating fraud in the workplace.

Lindsey McLain
Lindsey McLain
Lindsey is a Supervisor in the Special Investigation Unit at ICW Group. Lindsey has investigated 100s of cases; many resulting in criminal charges filed by state prosecutors, and thousands of dollars in restitution paid to ICW Group. In addition to conducting fraud investigations, she also presents and produces anti-fraud training for ICW Group personnel, and hosts fraud prevention webinars that reach thousands of customers nationwide.

Related Articles

Protect Loved Ones from Elder Fraud

An especially terrible type of fraud is elder fraud. There are far too many scammers who specifically prey on older individuals. Steps to minimize risk to the seniors in your...

Telemedicine Fraud Scams That Might Surprise You

One of the questions our Special Investigations Unit (SIU) has received from business partners relates to the types of telemedicine fraud we saw during the pandemic.  The SIU community and...

Best Practices for Using Video Surveillance Cameras in the Workplace

Video surveillance cameras in the workplace shield employers and workers alike. Many organizations, particularly those with cash or inventory, such as retail and financial institutions, have video surveillance. Businesses...