Investigation Update: Plumber Scam Results in $104,000 Restitution

Following up on a work comp fraud case we featured in an article last year, a 28-year-old San Diego plumber pled guilty to felony insurance fraud charges surrounding his attempt to defraud an ICW Group policyholder and the workers’ compensation system.  

Extensive surveillance showed this gentleman off-roading and working as a plumber on the side – all the while receiving benefits under a workers’ compensation claim. This gentleman claimed to be in severe pain and unable to work, even at a sedentary work assignment. His misrepresentations ultimately resulted in extensive medical treatment and diagnostics, in addition to payments for the time he claimed he was unable to work in any capacity.    

In light of the guilty conviction, the court pursued restitution. At a hearing in April 2022, a representative from ICW Group’s Special Investigations Unit (SIU) testified on all of the claim expenses incurred. Testimony also included educating the parties about the costs associated with the workers’ compensation process. The defendant’s attorney argued against the restitution figure presented to the court. The Judge ultimately rejected the attorney’s arguments and approved a full restitution award in the amount of $104,000. The defendant will now be making arrangements to reimburse his debt of ill-begotten gains.  

This plumber scam is one example of how ICW Group fights fraudulent workers’ compensation claims. If you suspect fraud, call our anti-fraud hotline at 855.ICW.FRAUD (855.429.3728).

Teresa Chandler
Teresa Chandler
Teresa Chandler is a Senior Special Investigations Unit Investigator with ICW Group. She served in the U.S. Navy as a Gunner's Mate for over ten years, with two deployments during Operation Enduring Freedom. She obtained her BS degree in Criminal Justice Administration and was a claims adjuster for over three years before coming to ICW Group in 2017. She is a native San Diegan, the oldest of six siblings (two Marine brothers), a world traveler, a cat mom, and an occasional dog foster mom. She also loves hiking and event planning.

Related Articles

ICW Group’s Anti-Fraud Team is Top of Its Field

ICW Group remains at the forefront of industry trends, scams, and exposures within the insurance community. Our entire Special Investigations Unit (SIU) staff are members of multiple anti-fraud trade associations,...

Watch for These Common Scams

Did you know the first recorded scam dates back to 300 B.C.? That’s right. Over 2,000 years ago! It's believed that Hegestratos, a Greek sea merchant, purchased an insurance policy on...

Fast Food Employee’s Work Comp Claim Doesn’t Stack Up

This case involves a fast-food employee who reported a slab of ice fell on her right arm. She was taken off work and treated for many months, yet continued...